Scientists have run experiments where parents talk to their babies and young children in a conversational tone, then turn away. When they turn back and present an immobile, blank face, the children become so confused and frightened they may start to cry.
In a ‘still face’ experiment, Dr Edward Tronick, Director of the Child Development Centre at Harvard University researched how important expression is in natural interaction with babies. In a YouTube video (Tronick, 2009), you can see how a baby reacts when her mum stops her normal responsiveness and replaces it with a blank face. The baby becomes visibly distressed.
When an adult is responsive to an infant, they learn about emotions, social engagement, and other elements of communication. When the parent’s responsiveness is interrupted, the infant becomes overwrought and tries several of the usual, already learned ways to regain the attention and connection of the relationship. Secure and successful interactions with positive facial expressions are key to a child’s development of trust through a healthy sense of attachment. Attachment theory, researched by John Bowlby, of the Royal College of Psychiatrists, suggests that children who do not experience strong attachment at an early age can display many problems of disconnection, negative self-image and behavioural difficulties later in life (Bowlby, 1977).
Before your child understands language, they are already learning about the world and themselves via your facial expressions and gestures. They start to mirror your expressions from the first time you look into their eyes. They develop an understanding of the patterns of your behaviour. They know when you are happy to see them, when you are impatient and when you become irritable.
If you are aware of how influential your expressions and communications are, you are well equipped to shape your child’s emotional intelligence from an early age. They are wired to imitate what you do more than what you say.
As children get older they learn the vocabulary that accompanies your expressions and gestures. The words and actions reinforce one another. It is extremely helpful to name and discuss emotions during daily family interactions. And talking out loud about your thoughts helps children to know what is going on in your mind which is generally invisible to them. They may not know why your are feeling frustrated about a late postal delivery unless you explain the logic behind your emotion.
It’s important to help them explain their own emotions. You might say, ‘I can see from your face that you are feeling disappointed you can’t go out with dad today, but he will be home this evening and he’ll have time to tell you the caterpillar story. When I feel disappointed, I try to think of something special I can look forward to.’
This way, you are combining a word, an explanation and a strategy for managing emotion into one brief communication.
It is a good idea to have a mirror at hand sometimes so children can see themselves using their happy, sad, excited, angry, grumpy, silly and frustrated expressions. I’m sure we’ve all seen children at a looking glass trying out their expressions in a looking glass. Knowing each of the words, helps them to process their expressions. Without these skills and vocabulary, many children find it hard to distinguish between their emotions and feel overwhelmed. Having a name, explanation and strategy goes a long way to making them masters of their feelings. This is great for family life, but it also makes your children more successful in social situations. They will both recognise emotions in others and project appropriate expressions that support social understanding to make the most of every encounter.
I’m not suggesting you try out your scary face this Halloween but be aware of how important knowledge about expression and gesture are to develop your child’s emotional awareness. Now it’s time to plan those tricks and treats.
Lili-Ann Kriegler (B. A Hons, H. Dip. Ed, M.Ed.) is a Melbourne-based education consultant and award-winning author. Lili-Ann writes to share the wisdom she has acquired through her training and 30 years of experience in education. She is a child, parent and family advocate who believes that education is a transformative force for humanity.
Website: https://www.kriegler-education.com/
]]>But how do we prepare our children for success?
One answer is to offer children rich and varied learning experience when they are young. Modern children attend preschool or formal schooling and they often attend numerous extra-curricular activities including sports, arts, social and educational activities outside of school hours. A child may be so busy with enriching music, cognitive programs, early reading lessons, dance and sport that they get home in time to eat, bathe and fall into bed!
No-one is arguing against the benefits of any one of these pursuits, but we have to assess whether our children may not be over-scheduled? Are they involved in so many directed activities, that they no longer have time to determine their own actions, think their own thoughts and follow the possibilities in their own imaginations? We also have to be aware of the impact of modern technology on their time.
In ‘Tools of the Mind’, the theories of learning from the renowned Russian psychologist Lev Vygotsky are elaborated. He believed of the power of play in learning. Based on his work, many research studies have been carried out about the positive outcomes of play.
Play, including dramatisation, leads to gains in thinking, social development and school-related skills. These include speech, language comprehension, imagination, concentration, self-regulation, curiosity, problem solving, empathy and group participation’
To gain a sense of this, we need only ask parents of young children to recall their own childhoods. They will no doubt remember having time outdoors with siblings and friends, having a few cherished toys and possibly even leaving their own backyards to play with friends in the neighbourhood. They might relate how they played on the beach, climbed trees, dandled their feet in water and spent time engrossed in imaginative play where their personas as pirates, superheroes, mermaids, kittens, dragons, teachers and mums and dads consumed their thoughts for hours.
When children are continuously regulated in their thoughts and actions, they don’t learn to script their own thoughts and behaviour. Their engagement becomes passive and they learn to merely follow instructions. If they spend hours in front of television or at the interface with a screen, this is also true.
When children are playing, they are learning how the world works. They are exploring relationships and social roles; they are trying out new perspectives and unpacking what is going on around them. They project themselves into the future and into the past. They even cross over into fantasy where they create and solve problems in collaboration with others.
Certain kinds of play are even excellent seedbeds of knowledge for reading, writing and maths.
For example block construction is great for learning. As children build, narratives develop around the construction and each participant is equally involved in developing the ideas. The blocks may be homes, work places, modes of transport, or scenes for playing out fantasies. It is always serious work and it can occupy the children for several hours. Children are learning about motives, emotions and socially acceptable mores.
Many mathematical concepts are incorporated like number, shape, symmetry, balance, matching and comparing. As their experience increases, the buildings will become more and more complex. Generally the building develops horizontally to begin with and spreads out. Later, when children learn to balance and match the blocks, they proceed to vertical constructions that are highly organised and may be elaborated with intricate decoration.
The benefits described in block play extend to other kinds of play with friends and siblings like running a store, manning a hospital, creating a restaurant, looking after pets or simply experiment with a collections of objects. Who cannot relate how they saw an infant play with a cardboard box for hours; or how a shell collection or bag of bottle tops became the best kind of toy?
Parents of this generation may also recall time spent playing board games and team games with their parents and siblings. These old-fashioned games were wonderful for developing strategies and for developing planning behaviour. Once again, maths, language and other general knowledge skills were being developed.
Add to this learning, the warmth and support experienced in play with family members, and we begin to sketch out what our youngest citizens may be missing out on as they are harried and hurried from one organised activity to another.
We also need to think about children’s physical development. Because children are being hurried and their time scheduled, they have less time to spend using their bodies freely in play. Running unhampered, jumping, climbing, creating the world into a spontaneous obstacle course and dancing for joy need to be reintroduced into children’s daily lives. We currently have the greatest percentage of obese children in history.
As parents make plans for their families, it is important for them to recognise the value of and to consider simple ‘me time’ and ‘play time’ for their children. In doing so, parents might even catch a little ‘me time’ for themselves!
Lili-Ann Kriegler (B. A Hons, H. Dip. Ed, M.Ed.) is a Melbourne-based education consultant and award-winning author. Lili-Ann writes to share the wisdom she has acquired through her training and 30 years’ experience in education. She is a child, parent and family advocate who believes that education is a transformative force for humanity. Website: https://www.kriegler-education.com/
]]>As children grow older, increase the complexity of the books. Picture books with more text and involved plots can be followed with chapter books. J.K Rowling is probably responsible for accelerating the reading age of my children by three years because they tired of being limited to the single pre-bed chapter and decided to read themselves! As young adults both are still prodigious readers. Let’s take a look at 5 things that you can do to foster their love of learning:
Reading should be enjoyable. Get comfortable, read with expression and choose age-appropriate books about something children find interesting. Books with repetitions, rhymes and resonating onomatopoeia like ‘bang’, ‘boom’, ‘crash’ and’ zap’ are ever popular! Don’t stop during the first reading! Too many questions or comments spoil a good story! On subsequent readings you can expand their understanding. They remember each story so well they’ll let you know if you sneakily try to skip a page!
Children benefit from discussing how pictures, words and symbols all add meaning. Pictures often provide information that is not in the text and vice versa. I recently read a beautiful book called ‘Collecting Sunshine’ by Rachel Flynn and Tamsin Ainslie with a group of three-year old children. Besides the main plot about children going walking to collect treasures a couple of budgerigars and some mischievous cats are ‘telling’ their graphic stories in delightful sub plots. The children were enthralled.
Stories have structural elements and older children benefit from knowing them. When you talk about Paddington Bear, a firm favourite of mine, mention that he is the main character. Rather than say ‘I wonder what will happen next’, say,’ I wonder what’s next in the plot. Focus on the story’s setting. Highlight the problem that the characters are solving and unpack how incidents advance or add twists to the story. Mention that stories have a beginning, middle and end. Have your child make up a story that includes these elements. As a family, it’s entertaining to create progressive stories. The first person introduces a character, setting and action and then the next person builds on it. A hairy, grey monster rose out of the sea…
Reading requires thinking skills and as children advance you can focus on four. Occasionally ask them to predict what will happen. To do this, they combine information from the current story, their understanding of how stories work in general and their collective prior knowledge. They will like this challenge and relish being right.
Check that they are monitoring what has happened to a certain point. Written language builds on itself, and if something is missed or misinterpreted, it can impede comprehension. Who stole the bicycle, where was it taken, who sold it, who bought it, and why was that strange?
Encourage your children to ask questions when they don’t get something. Questioning is an underestimated learning tool and asking you for explanations might prime them to do it when they find things confusing in the classroom.
At the end of reading, ask for a summation of what happened? Being able to remember the key linkages is a vital skill and is needed in many situations!
As time passes children recognise letters, identify sound patterns, read words and whole sentences. They become readers! When they’re ready it’s beneficial for them to read texts alongside story tapes. Give them choices by visiting the library to select a variety of texts including poems and allocate time and a reading space where they can disappear down the reading rabbit hole. This will foster a life-long love of literature.
My grandfather made a wooden wagon large enough for my younger sister and brother to sit in. For several years I’d haul them weekly to our local library. My childhood was populated with fabulous characters, faraway lands and gripping adventures. I wish this for your children and they will be richer for it.
Lili-Ann Kriegler (B. A Hons, H. Dip. Ed, M.Ed.) is an education consultant and author of ‘Edu-Chameleon’. Lili-Ann’s primary specialisations are in early childhood education (birth-9 years), leadership and optimising human thinking and cognition. Her current part-time role is as an education consultant at Independent Schools Victoria and she runs her own consultancy, Kriegler-Education. Find out more at https://kriegler-education.com
]]>There are many reasons why two- and three-year-old children experience tantrums. But, the most important is that they aren’t choosing to. They are not being manipulative. They are simply overwhelmed by uncontrollable feelings.
The ‘unselfish’, selfish child
According to Jean Piaget, the renowned child psychologist who researched children’s developmental stages, these small children experience the world in an egocentric way. Toddlers are focused on themselves, their immediate sensations and their experiences. They are ‘egocentric’ but not in the way that it is usually interpreted as self-obsessed or selfish. They are so busy learning who they are, what they feel and what happens in their world, that they can’t focus on and understand others. But that doesn’t mean you can’t lay down the foundations for empathy. Part of doing this is to understand toddlers’ egocentricity and work from where they are to develop their cooperation.
I have stood in a three-year-old kinder room, where a child spilt his drink, and his friend said, ‘never mind’, took his hand and walked to where the water jug and cups were situated for children to help themselves. That individual act counteracts the idea that children are entirely self-focused. The action indicates the child has absorbed a patient, supportive behaviour pattern from people around him. He might not be consciously deciding to do it, but he is mimicking what he’s experienced from others.
The egocentrism in toddlers is not ‘selfish’ in the way we use it for adults or older children. When children are learning language, they cannot immediately understand it fully. They use words like good, naughty, promise, love, share and doing favours but don’t yet have a genuine understanding of them. Your child might promise to be kind to the dog, but not understand that means not pulling its tail tomorrow as well as today! A ‘promise’ is a future contract, and like the other concepts mentioned, it is a very abstract idea.
Toddlers are still learning to project consequences
Toddlers don’t reason like adults and can’t always project consequences. They might not even remember fully what happened in the same situation when they pulled the tablecloth or slid on a mat a few days ago. So, it’s important to be patient. You can’t expect rational or even consistent behaviour. Mr ‘never mind’ from two paragraphs above, might demonstrate different behaviour when you try and tear him away from Bluey, his favourite cartoon dog, on the TV to have his bath.
More and more, as they grow up, toddlers see themselves as someone and something separate from others. And if they learn to do something for themselves, they will fiercely demand their right to do it! They start to know what they want, and they want to have it – now! Their behaviour varies from being very clingy and dependent to wanting to do EVERYTHING for themselves. You might have been subject to that great saying, ’You’re not the boss of me!’
Yes, these are the ‘terrible twos’. And toddlers can be very difficult. But their behaviours often relate to expectations, or beliefs, about them demonstrating purposeful misbehaviour, when in fact they are pretty much acting out their feelings and still consolidating how the world works.
Avoiding tantrums is not solved during the tirade, but in the way, your child is learning about emotions and how to manage them each day as they interact with you. Your children can be told what to do, but the most powerful way to teach them is to model what you want from them.
Like the three-year-old described earlier, children mirror what they see. If you, as the parent or primary caregiver, explain in simple terms how you feel and how you are managing your feelings, they will learn from you. Before you go to the supermarket, reason with your child. ‘We are going shopping and we’ll see so many things we can buy. I know I’ll see lots of things I want, but I’ll choose what we really need. You’ll also see lots of things, so you will choose one treat you really think we need. Then you can put that in the trolley. What do you think?’
This creates a mental map of the future for your child, so they are prepared for what is coming up.
I wish you luck with your toddlers. Time with these little ones passes quickly. Enjoy every moment. Even when your toddlers want to ‘be the boss of you!’
Lili-Ann Kriegler (B. A Hons, H. Dip. Ed, M.Ed.) is a Melbourne-based education consultant and author of Edu-Chameleon. Lili-Ann’s primary specialisations are in early childhood education (birth-9 years), leadership and optimising human thinking and cognition. She is a child, parent and family advocate who believes that education is a transformative force for humanity. Her current part-time role is as an education consultant at Independent Schools Victoria and she runs her own consultancy, Kriegler-Education. Find out more at https://kriegler-education.com
]]>The digital world has moved so fast for parents that many don’t understand how their kids are being influenced or targeted online. They underestimate the disastrous consequences of internet bullying, low self-esteem related to online activity and digital predation on young people.
Young people today appear linked to the internet by a virtual umbilical cord. We are all aware that every modern invention has a good and bad side. So, as wonderful as Facebook, Instagram, Twitter and other platforms are for social connection, they are equally capable of being used for social manipulation, bullying and predation. Education about the methodology of online predators is crucially important.
Kids love having digital followers. To acquire the following, they might decide to keep their profiles public. This makes them visible to literally anyone in the world including hackers, groomers, criminals and voyeurs. The daughter of a close acquaintance of mine was inveigled into an online ‘romance’ that cost her in excess of $10,000 because she was tricked into funding false cancer treatment for her online catfishing ‘beau’. The settings are available to keep a profile private and kids are better off limiting who can access theirs.
In a report from the Australian Federal Police (AFP) research found that despite ‘just under 17,000 reports of online child sexual exploitation received by the ACCCE in 2019, the Australian-first research found only 21% of parents and carers think there is a likelihood that online child sexual exploitation can happen to their child’ (AFP, 2020). It is reported in the same research study that ‘four out of five children aged four are using the internet; 30% of these children have access to their own device’ and ‘only 51% of the research participants sit with the children while they use the internet’.
The AFP works in partnership with the Commonwealth Bank of Australia, Datacom and Microsoft on an initiative called ThinkUKnow (Think U Know, 2021) which curates excellent resources for parents and educators with strategies to prevent children becoming targets or victims of online predation. The AFP also works with State and Territory Police on this initiative and it is well worth checking the advice on this platform.
Two final comments on the impact of digital platforms are worth mentioning. What young people post online doesn’t ever go away. It is almost impossible to delete or erase things that have left a device. Prospective employers are now using these platforms to check on and assess potential workers. Also, even things sent in confidence to someone trusted can be used against the sender if relationships sour. It is worth advising your children to regard everything they send as capable of ending up being public. Warn them to deeply consider what they post about themselves.
In September 2021, a Facebook whistle blower, Frances Haugen’s comments that the company’s own research indicated their platform, particularly Instagram, was having a negative effect on teenagers. The Wall Street Journal printed an article about the deleterious effects of viewing Instagram posts including anxiety, depression and eating disorders like bulimia and anorexia nervosa. Thirty-two percent of teen girls in the study said if they had poor body image, they felt worse about themselves. And young men are not immune with 14% of them also feeling worse after viewing Instagram (Wells, Horowitz, & Seetharaman, 2021).
Instagram’s head of public policy, Karina Newton commented in response saying that said the Wall Street Journal story had ‘focused on a limited set of findings and casts them in a negative light’. I have some sympathy with Newton’s statement, because researching the causality between social media on specific psychological and social outcomes is near impossible. It’s difficult to use the data generated by social media research. A statistic can’t capture the users’ family and social environment or assess their mental states as they engage on these platforms. If we could assess these elements, it would greatly improve the interpretation of the data. But, even if we can’t prove causality, we need to be aware of the issues.
When viewing social media platforms, children and young people are seeing everything from the outside. They cannot know the true circumstances or motives behind the posts. Not the real experiences, but a selection of the best of experiences are posted by celebrities and Instafamous people. Fear of missing out and envy of what kids perceive as others’ amazing normal may impact on their self-worth. And their sense of inferiority is built on false, artificial exteriors.
The negative impact of social platforms may have harmful effects on self-esteem. Low self-esteem is proven to reduce quality-of-life outcomes because it blunts risk-taking, reduces resilience to bounce back from mistakes and causes people to become stuck in negative thinking spirals. Feelings of insignificance, loneliness, withdrawal and listlessness have teens feeling like they are walking through treacle. It can lead kids to make destructive decisions including accepting mistreatment, self-harming, promiscuity or harming others (Solomons, 2013).
It is important this information about damaging effects is in the public arena, but will it help your tweens and teens in the immediate term? Social media has outrun legislation, societal norms and user impact because it has happened so fast. Unlike mainstream journalism, norms and protocols for social media are in their infancy. It is not even certain if the platforms are publishers or not. As publishers, social media giants would be subject to entrenched laws, but their status as publishers is still being debated.
Quite simply parents can’t rely on social media platforms to solve the problem, they have to engage with it themselves. It’s time to transform the situation and create a narrative of using youthful minds and bodies to experience life and achieve unique personal goals and to shift the focus away from ‘appearing’ and start a revolution of ‘doing’.
Parents have the power to influence this narrative from an early age, in fact, from infancy. What they say and how they say it can change how their children think. They can provide the activities that nurture a positive self-esteem. Thinking is the key to counteracting the powerful influences and manipulations emanating from social media.
As parents what you can do in the immediate term is work with your kids to hone social media literacy. We can help them to form a healthy balanced identity by applying advanced critical thinking. Good thinking can help them to navigate many of the deleterious influences that they will encounter.
Converse with your family to develop perspectival, thinking. Offer different points of view. If you commence doing this from an early age, and pay attention to their perspectives during conversations, they are likely to see the value in this thinking.
Frame the experience by examining together how the images these days are photoshopped and manipulated to create near impossible ideals of body perfection. And before the photoshopping, kids are only choosing to portray their most enviable selves. The one selfie out of twenty that makes them look good.
Also talk about appearance as the least important part of a full life. Emphasise how the body is the vehicle for achievement in a million other ways.
Embrace directed by Taryn Brumfitt, founder of Body Image Movement, is a well-researched punch packing film that shines a light on the issue. Taryn embarked on her film journey when she posted some reverse order photographs of herself. Her before image was her as a sculpted body builder, and her after image was taken when she had given birth to her baby. The photos caused a tsunami of negative comments. The film is her response, and every young person will learn from it (Brumfitt, 2016).
Presenting an optimistic view and offering realistic praise of their accomplishments can also counteract the effects of social media on their psyche.
The same 360° thinking can arm your kids with the ability to filter out fake news. Remarkably, kids these days are more immune to the influence of fake news than we think they are. They are possible more alert than we are.
As I write this, we are negotiating the roadmap out of intermittent COVID lockdowns in Victoria that have shaped the last 18 months. So truly there haven’t been many opportunities for face-to-face anything!
But involving kids in team sports, rock climbing, dance, music, drama, writing, cooking, baking or strategy games like chess are all great ways for them to interact with real people in real situations. Having part-time jobs provides them with key skills that will come in handy later in life and look great on their CVs when they start looking for work seriously.
Lili-Ann Kriegler (B. A Hons, H. Dip. Ed, M.Ed.) is a Melbourne-based education consultant and author of Edu-Chameleon. Lili-Ann’s primary specialisations are in early childhood education (birth-9 years), leadership and optimising human thinking and cognition. Her current part-time role is as an education consultant at Independent Schools Victoria and she runs her own consultancy, Kriegler-Education. Find out more at https://kriegler-education.com
]]>